Dec 8, 2014 3:23 PM

New policy widens profiling ban, with key caveats

The Associated Press

WASHINGTON (AP) The Obama administration released long-awaited racial profiling guidelines for federal law enforcement agents on Monday. The new rules broaden an existing decade-old ban on profiling, but contain significant exceptions that trouble some advocacy groups for minorities.

A closer look at the changes:

Q: What's new in the guidelines?

A: The guidelines prohibit the FBI and other federal law enforcement agencies from profiling on the basis of religion, national origin, gender, gender identity or sexual orientation. They replace 2003 directives from the Bush administration that banned profiling on the basis of race and ethnicity but created an exception for national security investigations. The new rules close that national security loophole and widen the profiling prohibition to include a broader set of characteristics.

Q. Does that mean federal law-enforcement agencies can never take those factors into account?

A. Not quite. The Justice Department says law enforcement may still consider those characteristics if there's information linking a suspect of, say, a particular ethnicity or gender to a specific crime. In other words, U.S. Park Police officers may not stop speeding motorists on the basis of race, gender or national origin. But they can use those factors to decide which drivers to pull over if they've been told to be on the lookout for a fleeing bank robbery suspect of a particular race or gender.

Beyond traffic stops, federal agents may also consider those factors if they have information connecting an individual of a certain gender or background to a national security threat, criminal plot or immigration law violation.

Q. What other exemptions exist?

A: The primary carve-outs are in airports and at the nation's borders. Security screens by Department of Homeland Security employees in airports and at border checkpoints are exempt from the new protocols, as are interdictions at ports of entry and Secret Service protective activities. The department argued that the "unique nature of border and transportation security as compared to traditional law enforcement" justified the exclusion of those activities.

Q: Are the new rules a response to recent police-involved deaths in Ferguson, Missouri, New York City and Cleveland?

A: No, the protocols have been under review since soon after Eric Holder became attorney general in 2009. Still, they're being released amid mounting concerns about the treatment of minorities by law enforcement and about the adequacy of police training. Holder said in announcing the new guidelines that "it's imperative that we take every possible action to institute strong and sound policing practices."

Q. How will this impact day-to-day policing across the country?

A. That's not clear. The guidelines are geared toward federal law enforcement officials from agencies including the FBI, Drug Enforcement Administration and the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives. They cover local and state officers the ones most likely to carry out day-to-day law enforcement in communities only when they're serving on federal task forces. Still, the Justice Department hopes the guidelines will be a voluntary template for local agencies, and Holder was briefing local law enforcement to encourage them to adopt the federal policy.

Q: What has been the reaction of groups that advocate for ethnic and religious groups, and for minorities?

A: Mixed at best. Though advocates say they're happy with the broadened protections, they're disappointed that the rules don't go further. They say they wish the guidelines were binding on local and state departments, not just federal agencies, and are disappointed with caveats that they say will still allow profiling in certain circumstances. One particular concern, in particular from Muslim advocacy groups, is that the guidelines won't bar the FBI from using neighborhood data on race, ethnicity and religion to recruit informants and develop information about where people of particular races or ethnicities live.


Follow Eric Tucker on Twitter at


--  Dealing with the Disease of Addiction? Click here for help --

More from

NH1 News Debates
NH1 News Replay

NH1 on Twitter

NH1 SkyView Cameras

NH1 on Facebook

Check out NH1 News Rail Polls on LockerDome on LockerDome