Mar 19, 2015 11:59 AM

In early states, Bush walks tightrope with conservatives

The Associated Press

MYRTLE BEACH, S.C. (AP) Jeb Bush is betting his political future these days on the hope that pragmatism will trump conservative hostility in 2016.

Fresh off his first public tours of Iowa, New Hampshire and South Carolina, the Republican White House prospect has settled on an early approach for dealing with skeptics on the right, casting himself as a practical but "principled conservative," particularly when explaining his immigration and education positions that put him at odds with the GOP's most conservative factions.

Bush often wraps his philosophy in scathing criticism of President Barack Obama. But the former Florida governor's theme is clear: He wants to be the grown-up who ends the Washington "food fight" and governs to "fix things for everybody, not to win a political argument."

"Washington needs principled, centered leadership, not leadership that tries to divide us," Bush told Republicans in Myrtle Beach, South Carolina, on Wednesday. "Our democracy doesn't work when you jam it down the throat of everybody else," he added. "It's not always about winning and losing. It's about forging consensus to solve some of these problems."

Bush's approach is a risky one in a Republican primary process where the GOP's most conservative voters wield considerable influence. It also contrasts with many of his likely Republican competitors, Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker among them, who take a more hard-line approach.

"He was not pandering," said Fergus Cullen, a former New Hampshire GOP chairman who held a Bush event at his home last weekend. Cullen noted that some conservatives left the event disappointed, but that Bush "was not trying to be something he's not."

It was much the same in Iowa at a recent agricultural conference, where Bush didn't always offer the easy red meat. "He's making a priority to reach out to conservatives in Iowa," said Steve Scheffler, the state's Republican national committeeman. "He certainly didn't hurt himself."

In the early voting states, Bush has explaining his endorsement of Common Core education standards and his call for an immigration overhaul first by contrasting his stance with Obama, then framing his argument as true to conservative priorities.

On immigration, he emphasizes border security and blasts Obama's enforcement of existing law. Only then does Bush detail his own proposals, including a warning that "you can't deport 11 million people" who are already in the country illegally. Instead, he wants to "give people a path to earned legal status over a long period of time." And he's willing to push back when pressed.

"Look, I'm pretty convinced that my views on this are the right views for sustained economic growth," Bush said at a business breakfast in Greenville, South Carolina. "If there's a better idea, I'd like to hear it. But doing nothing? That's not a plan."

In Myrtle Beach, when one local GOP activist bemoaned that "illegals" will get "$1 trillion in benefits," Bush skeptically asked for his source and gave the questioner his personal email address to send him the proof.

For his part, Walker has acknowledged changing his position on immigration. As early as 2002, he supported creating a pathway to citizenship for immigrants living in the country illegally. In an interview with Fox News this month, Walker said he no longer supports "amnesty."

"My view has changed," he said. "I'm flat out saying it." He attributed the flip to conversations with voters and border-state governors.

Holding to the center in primaries often dominated by the right surely won't make for easy sailing for Bush. His nuanced positions on touchy issues could give his rivals plenty of fodder.

For example, Cary Powell, a financial services executive in Myrtle Beach, liked Bush's presentation but said he will have to "come up with some sound bites" to use on the debate stage, where he won't have 10 minutes to detail his immigration position. "He's got to have something to counter his opponents who will say, 'amnesty, amnesty, amnesty,'" Powell said.

Norm Fay, a retiree in Myrtle Beach, said: "He says you can't deport 11 million people. Fine. So tell me how many you can deport 500,000? A million? To me that's a bogus argument."

On education, Walker and another potential rival, Louisiana Gov. Bobby Jindal, previously supported the voluntary Common Core guidelines developed by state leaders from both parties. But they changed course after tea party conservatives condemned the standards as a Washington takeover of classrooms.

Bush asserts that education gaps must be a national priority but standards are administered at the local level. "That's federalism," he said. "That's how the founders envisioned the system working."


Peoples reported from Washington.


Follow the reporters on Twitter at and .


--  Dealing with the Disease of Addiction? Click here for help --

More from

NH1 News Debates
NH1 News Replay

NH1 on Twitter

NH1 SkyView Cameras

NH1 on Facebook

Check out NH1 News Rail Polls on LockerDome on LockerDome