Mar 28, 2017 4:45 PM
NH1 Political Director - NH1.com
CONCORD – New numbers from New Hampshire’s Secretary of State’s office indicate that 458 people who voted here on Election Day may have possibility committed voter fraud.
Or as President Donald Trump would possibly say, that’s about seven or eight busloads of people.
It’s been nearly five months since November’s presidential election, but in New Hampshire arguments are still on-going over the president’s claims of illegal voting in the Granite State.
Multiple times since Election Day, Trump has claimed that people from Massachusetts were bused into New Hampshire to vote illegally. The president’s argument has fueled support among Granite State conservatives for Republican backed bills that would tighten New Hampshire’s voting laws. An important showdown looms Thursday in the state Senate over the measure with the best chance of becoming law.
Regardless of the outcome of the legislation, the fight continues over Trump’s allegations. Is the president correct? Was there massive voter fraud in the Granite State?
The 458 people in those latest numbers from the Secretary of State’s office, which was provided to NH1 News on Monday, could potentially have made an impact on close contests here, such as the battle between incumbent GOP Sen. Kelly Ayotte and Democratic challenger Gov. Maggie Hassan. Ayotte lost re-election by just over 1,000 votes.
Figures released earlier this year from the Secretary of State’s office indicate that nearly 6,000 first-time New Hampshire voters in the November election used an out-of-state identification, with many of those people casting ballots in towns in and around colleges and universities. All legal under state law, but adding fuel to arguments by New Hampshire Republicans who are advocating for changes to the state’s election laws.
First, a little history
Trump lost the fight for the Granite State’s four electoral votes by just under 3,000 votes to Democratic presidential nominee Hillary Clinton, out of more than 700,000 cast. And even though he convincingly won the all-important Electoral College vote, he lost the national popular vote count to Clinton by some 3 million votes.
In November, then-President-Elect Trump claimed in a tweet that he would have won the national popular vote if not for the “millions” of undocumented immigrants who cast ballots against him. He also alleged, without offering proof, that there was “serious voter fraud” in New Hampshire, Virginia, and California.
In February, at a meeting with a bipartisan group of 10 U.S. senators in which he was making a pitch for his Supreme Court nominee Neil Gorsuch, Trump once again revived the allegations. Ayotte, who was shepherding Gorsuch through the Senate, was also attending the meeting. According to multiple reports, Trump said that he and Ayotte would have won in New Hampshire if not for voters bused in from out of state.
Many Granite State conservatives have long accused New Hampshire Democrats of gaming the system by bringing in people from out-of-state to vote on Election Day, thanks to the state’s same-day registration law.
Just days before the November election, then-GOP gubernatorial nominee Chris Sununu told conservative radio host Howie Carr “there’s no doubt there’s election fraud.”
He added that Democrats “have really gamed the system in their advantage.”
But three weeks after the election, Sununu said he didn’t believe there was voter fraud. And in an interview with NH1 News in December, he said, “We don’t have fraud in this state, but we do have laws that are a little bit loose. There’s a lot of gray area. A lot of room for interpretation about who’s a resident.”
Sununu, the first GOP governor in a dozen years, continues to say he’s seen no evidence of massive voter fraud, but he’s also a strong supporter of the Republican bills to tighten up the state’s election laws.
Now, let’s break down those numbers
According to data released earlier this year from the Secretary of State’s office following a public records request from NHPR, 5,903 first time New Hampshire voters who registered on Election Day last November used an out-of-state license as their form of identification. That’s 0.78% of all people who voted in the election.
Yes, people with out-of-state licenses can show up and vote on Election Day in New Hampshire. They could be people who recently moved to the state and haven’t had a chance yet to obtain a New Hampshire driver’s license, or they may be out-of-staters attending college here. That’s allowed in the Granite State, as long as those students don’t vote in their home states.
But to vote with an out-of-state license, you need to prove you hold domicile in the state. Showing a utility bill, a lease or a pay stub, can work to prove you actually live in New Hampshire.
Of those 5,903 people who voted last November using an out-of-state license, nearly 40 percent came from Massachusetts. Another 33 percent used licenses from the other states in New England and New York.
More than 4,000 of those 5,903 people using out-of-state licenses to register voted in towns with a high percentage of college students, such as Durham (home to the University of New Hampshire), Hanover and Lebanon (Dartmouth College), Keene (Keene State University), Plymouth (Plymouth State University), Rindge (Franklin Pierce University), Henniker (New England College), and the Manchester area (SNHU and Saint Anselm University).
We don’t know the party identification of those first-time voters using out-of-state ID’s, or how they actually voted. But we do know that those towns and cities with colleges and university consistently give Democratic candidates a big boost in elections.
While those votes are legal, they do feed into the arguments by conservatives that out-of-staters are influencing and possibly swaying Granite State elections. Especially in close contests, like last November’s Trump-Clinton and Ayotte-Hassan races.
It’s worth noting that the Statehouse bill with the best chance of becoming law tightens up the process for out-of-state voters to prove they are domiciled in New Hampshire, but it doesn’t prevent out-of-state college students going to school here from voting.
So who voted illegally?
Voters without any proof that they live New Hampshire are allowed to cast their ballot, but they have to sign a legal document confirming they’re telling the truth about where they live. Signing that document opens them up to the possibility of prosecution if it’s proven they lied.
Within 90 days after the election, the Secretary of State’s office mails letters to those people signing those affidavits. According to documents provided to NH1 News this week by the Secretary of State’s office, 6,033 letters were sent to people who voted in New Hampshire last November without proof of domicile. As highlighted earlier, 458 of those letters came back undeliverable. Many of the names of those people will be sent to the state Department of Justice for investigation and possible prosecution.
It’s worth noting that the 458 undeliverable letters is down from 1,193 four years ago, when a new law allowing the follow up from the Secretary of State’s office was implemented for the first time.
The Secretary of State’s office also sent out 764 letters following this past November’s election to voters who cast a ballot without a satisfactory photo identification. The is no information yet on how many of those letters were returned undeliverable.
When it comes to voter fraud, perception may be as important as reality.
New Hampshire Deputy Secretary of State Dave Scanlan recently told NH1 News that, “we don’t see any widespread voter fraud taking place in New Hampshire. Does it happen in isolated instances? I think the answer is yes. There have been prosecutions in the past.”
But pointing to the comments from the President, Scanlan added that “voter perception is as important as the reality in elections. People, voters, have to have confidence that their elections are operating properly, fairly, with integrity. And there is a fairly high level of lack of confidence in the elections nationwide.”
15 hours 26 minutes agoA Somersworth man is being accused of sexually assaulting a 4-year-old girl in front of his 9-year-old daughter. (More)
17 hours 8 minutes agoPolice said a large dog was shot by a dog owner after it attacked and injured the owner's small dog in a Hooksett rest...
20 hours 48 minutes agoMultiple teenagers are left without a job this summer after one town violated child labor laws. (More)
19 hours 39 minutes agoN.H. State Police issued a reminder to drivers about strapping items to the roof of their vehicles after they stopped a van with way...
22 hours 52 seconds agoMeth, pills, heroin and non-appearance charges are behind the arrest of several NH men in the latest Granite Hammer operation in Nashua. (More)
22 hours 27 minutes agoA Somersworth man was arrested Tuesday after police said he sexually assaulted an underage girl early Sunday morning. (More)
Jun 27, 2017 1:47 PMGrandparents bill signed by NH Gov. Sununu strengthens protections for grandparents raising grandchildren due to parents' incarceration or drug addiction. (More)
Jun 27, 2017 8:42 AMA mother's tweets sharing her son's hospital bill have gone viral as Senate Republicans are working to pass a new health care bill. (More)
Jun 27, 2017 1:11 PMA woman was arrested Friday after police found her home filled with trash, rats and animal waste. (More)
Jun 26, 2017 3:17 PMAn 80-year-old woman went out to close her chickens up and pick weeds form her garden, when a bobcat viciously attacked her. (More)
Jun 27, 2017 7:58 AMA video of a man apparently overdosing next to a woman in a vehicle and an officer coming to his aid in Boston has...
Jun 27, 2017 11:57 AMThe latest Snapchat feature could place you in harm's way, the Concord Police Department warns. (More)
Jun 27, 2017 8:47 AMThe family of a teenage lifeguard who vanished from her post at a Massachusetts pond in 2000 has released a new video on the...
Jun 27, 2017 9:23 AMStorms will develop this afternoon. (More)
Jun 26, 2017 4:02 PMA New Hampshire man is being indicted with the second-degree murder and manslaughter of his 3-year-old daughter early last year. (More)
Jun 26, 2017 5:08 PMA neighbor who witnessed the massive fire destroy Stenton Trust Mill said arson was inevitable due to the increased activity inside the abandoned building....
Jun 26, 2017 9:14 AMMassachusetts man drives a personal watercraft up and inside boat full of children on Great Pond. (More)
Jun 25, 2017 11:37 AMIn an effort to crack down on impaired driving, the New Hampshire State Police are setting up a sobriety checkpoint in Nashua. (More)
Jun 24, 2017 9:44 AMThe highest tide of the month flooded parts of Hampton overnight. (More)
Jun 25, 2017 10:40 AMOfficials say a NH man who crashed his boat onto rocks on the shore of Lake Winnipesaukee has been charged with operating under the...
Jun 24, 2017 8:51 AMAfter sifting through numerous tips, police believe they have a suspect in the assault of a woman outside of Planet Fitness on June 12....
Jun 23, 2017 11:29 AM38 teenagers were arrested on alcohol-related charges after police broke up a gathering in Georges Mills Thursday night. (More)
Jun 23, 2017 12:14 PMAn inmate who escaped from a transport vehicle Thursday was captured in Concord Friday morning. (More)
Jun 22, 2017 2:40 PMA man was sentenced to 10 to 20 years in prison for physically overpowering and raping a 14-year-old girl in an unused hallway of...
Jun 22, 2017 12:34 PMAn elderly woman confused the brakes in the car with the gas, launching her into Lake Winnipesaukee. (More)
Jun 21, 2017 8:49 AMMost Granite Staters have encountered a tick at least once in their lifetime, but a meat allergy caused by a bite from a southeastern...
Jun 22, 2017 9:37 AMWhile Manchester PD arrests 5 people for prostitution, undercover detective offered heroin and discovers man with crystal methamphetamine. (More)
Jun 22, 2017 6:20 PMThe United States Marshal's office is searching for an escaped inmate who may be in the area of Belknap or Merrimack counties. (More)
Jun 21, 2017 6:19 PMBefore planning a day trip to a New Hampshire beach or pond, make sure to check that the water is not contaminated with fecal...
Jun 22, 2017 9:47 AMThe Department of Health and Human Services report a syphilis outbreak in the state, which is consistent with the national trend. (More)
Jun 21, 2017 3:57 PMDuring an interview, an abused child told detectives the man 'always hurts me almost every time' the two are together. (More)
Jun 21, 2017 3:42 PMWho is Christina Fay? What we know about her before she was arrested for housing 84 Great Danes in deplorable conditions at her Wolfeboro...
Jun 21, 2017 11:51 AMA potential funnel cloud was caught on camera. (More)
Jun 21, 2017 12:22 PMOn Tuesday afternoon police arrested a man for allegedly abusing a young boy he was watching. (More)
Jun 20, 2017 2:06 PM15,351 students at the University of New Hampshire can sleep peacefully knowing their campus has been ranked as the safest school in the Uunited...
Jun 20, 2017 3:45 PMPolice are looking to speak with a Somersworth woman after finding a car involved in a hit-and-run that killed a 71-year-old woman. (More)
Jun 20, 2017 11:39 AMTwo young children were present when police searched a Massachusetts apartment Monday night and arrested a man on multiple drug distribution charges. (More)
Jun 20, 2017 2:28 PMNew Hampshire State Police are hoping that video surfaced out of California may help lead to clues to solve the case of a serial...
Jun 19, 2017 1:13 PMA New Hampshire school district is mourning the loss of their superintendent after he died from a sudden illness. (More)
Jun 19, 2017 8:11 AMWhile investigating suspected money laundering, FBI recorded the man claiming he won money while in Colorado hunting Bigfoot. (More)
Jun 19, 2017 12:57 PMMany parents in New Hampshire probably believe their baby is the cutest in the state, but one competition is looking to say otherwise. (More)
Jun 19, 2017 4:30 PMPolice released the identity of a Massachusetts man who was killed after being involved in a three vehicle crash along Route 3A. (More)
Jun 18, 2017 2:32 PMThose looking to adopt the Great Danes rescued at a suspected New Hampshire puppy mill may have to wait up to a year to...
Jun 18, 2017 8:42 PMThunderstorms are likely to be strong Monday afternoon and evening. (More)
Jun 19, 2017 12:25 PMA Severe Thunderstorm Watch has been issued for all of New Hampshire until 8 p.m. Monday. (More)
Jun 18, 2017 10:23 AMThe Somersworth Police Department are searching for the suspected driver who hit and killed a pedestrian. (More)
Jun 18, 2017 12:11 PMThree New Hampshire teenagers have been charged with assaulting a popular street performer in Boston who plays music while dressed as a bear. (More)
Jun 18, 2017 10:46 AMOfficers arrested three men at a New Hampshire homeless shelter after they resisted arrest by trying to take an officer's gun and hitting officers,...
Jun 18, 2017 11:17 AMDonations to The Humane Society of the United States helped ease the rescue of 84 Great Danes from a New Hampshire puppy mill. (More)