Sep 1, 2016 11:06 PM
NH1 News Political Director
CONCORD – Sen. Kelly Ayotte and her Republican primary challenger battled over illegal immigration, free trade deals, fiscal issues, special interests, and even Donald Trump, in the first debate in New Hampshire’s blockbuster U.S. Senate race.
While Ayotte’s general election match up with Gov. Maggie Hassan, her Democratic challenger, dominates the race, the incumbent still has a long shot primary challenge on her hands from former state Sen. Jim Rubens. The two candidates faced off Thursday night in an NH1 News debate.
Rubens went on the attack soon after the start of the debate, criticizing Ayotte over her 2013 vote in favor of a bipartisan immigration reform bill.
“Unfortunately Senator, you promised to vote against amnesty and to secure the border when you ran last time in 2010. And you broke that promise. You went to Washington and voted for the Gang of Eight, open borders, amnesty, drive down American wages bill,” Rubens charged.
Ayotte defended her past Senate votes on the issue, saying “I feel strongly that we need to secure our border and protect the American people. That’s why the proposal that I voted for would have doubled the amount of fencing, would have doubled the amount of border agents, would have created an entry-exit system. And in fact 40% of the people who are here illegally actually overstayed a visa so we need that system. We need a stronger E-Verify system. And I have voted to end sanctuary cities.”
A few minutes later, Rubens attacked again, this time over the Trans Pacific Partnership (TPP), a proposed free trade deal involving the U.S. and nearly a dozen Pacific nations. Last year Ayotte voted in favor of the bipartisan Trade Promotion Authority (TPA) legislation, which gave President Obama fast track authority to negotiate the TPP deal.
“We need fair trade policies that do not lead to us bleeding jobs to other countries. So I oppose TPP, I oppose TPA, because it will result in more deterioration of American wages,” he stated. “I differ with my opponent on these crony capitalist trade deals. Totally unfair for Americans.”
Ayotte disagreed, saying “I’ve visited so many great companies in New Hampshire, manufacturing companies. Companies that do great work in producing incredible goods. And they’re exporting a lot of their goods overseas and they do incredible work. And I know that our companies, they can compete in the very best, and are the very best, when there’s a fair playing field. So I did allow the President to negotiate this. But I can’t support it as it’s come forward because he did not negotiate it strongly enough.”
In a rare moment, Ayotte then mentioned the name of the GOP presidential nominee, saying “this is where I agree with Donald Trump, because I think he would be a much stronger negotiator.”
Ayotte’s kept her distance from Trump, saying she’ll vote for him but not endorse him. And in an editorial board meeting earlier this week she said that Trump has not always in the past been totally honest or trustworthy.
Asked in the NH1 News debate about that comment and whether she’d still vote for Trump, Ayotte responded “think about Sec. Hillary Clinton and the lies that she has told. I think that certainly I trust him much more than her.”
But Rubens criticized Ayotte for her stance regarding the GOP nominee, saying “I will vote for Donald Trump and I will endorse him and I have endorsed him. Anything less than this is a support for Hillary Clinton.”
A fiscal fight
Rubens also questioned Ayotte’s fiscal conservative credentials.
“You promised to be a fiscal conservative when you ran in 2010. I supported you in 2010 and worked to get you elected. You get down there. You drink the Washington cool aid and you voted for the Democrats and Obama’s cromibus and omnibus budgets. These are the last two budgets. The proof is in the vote. And you voted to add trillions of dollars to national debt,” Rubens charged.
“You voted recently, last year, to gut, to take $117 billion from the Social Security Trust Fund to fund Welfare. You voted to remove the debt ceiling. These are not the acts of a fiscal conservative. This is fundamental to what Republican stand for. We’re having a primary here so we can have people in the United States Senate who will vote for fiscal responsibility” he added.
Responding, Ayotte said “I strongly support getting our fiscal house in order.. I’ve supported a balanced budget amendment and on every committee that I serve on I’m looking for ways to cut spending and have examples of how I’ve done that. But I want people to understand the things that Mr. Rubens is criticizing me on, the bills that I did support, to make sure that the military had the funding to take on ISIS, to make sure that those resources that I talked about for the heroin epidemic were coming to New Hampshire. And also suspending the medical device tax that is so onerous under Obamacare. Those are important issues for New Hampshire that I wasn’t going to overlook.”
Late in the debate, Rubens accused Ayotte of being in the pockets of special interests.
“You’ve taken tens of millions of bucks from special interests in Washington and it’s the only way you can explain why you would vote to bankrupt the country and fill the budget with so much pork. Why you would vote to leave the borders open and why you would vote for tripling of H-1B visas that are driving down wages for technical workers right here in New Hampshire. I can’t explain it any other way,” he charged.
Ayotte shot back, saying “let me just be clear, it’s not true what Mr. Rubens just said. But let me just be clear about this. I do have special interests. People like Barbara Moussette, who was going to lose her home because she was a victim of identity theft, that I fought the IRS for. People like our veterans who need better quality care, and who I fight for every single day. Our men and women who serve at the Portsmouth Naval Shipyard, and our guard. Absolutely, every day I wake up to fight for people in New Hampshire and that’s why I do this.”
The NH1 News debate came just 12 days before the Granite State’s Sept. 13 primary.
11 hours 14 minutes agoChelsea Blais plead not guilty to abusing children in her care at the Alpha Bits Learning Center, where police say she force fed and...
6 hours 9 minutes agoNew Hampshire is often in the 'weather battle zone' this time of year, which isn't a good thing if you are looking for spring...
11 hours 30 minutes agoNew Hampshire’s top public officials Wednesday marked the death of state Sen. Scott McGilvray. The first term Democratic state senator from Hooksett and president...
12 hours 38 seconds agoNYPD seized over $4.1 million and over three kilograms (6 pounds) of heroin, unraveling a multi-state drug ring — involving New England. (More)
11 hours 7 minutes agoPolice respond after call that a man at 16 Foster Avenue was known to have firearms and had made concerning remarks. (More)
14 hours 42 minutes agoThe National Weather Service has issued a wind advisory from 10 a.m. Wednesday to midnight. (More)
23 hours 46 minutes agoA report released on Tuesday by the state agency that licenses childcare centers revealed multiple incidents of verbal and physical abuse committed by a...
Mar 21, 2017 6:40 PMA mother and her friend who injected her with heroin while she was in labor in September 2016 will not be facing felony charges...
Mar 21, 2017 4:09 PMA 74-year-old Mass. man living in public housing for the elderly faces drug trafficking charges after police say they found cocaine valued at about...
Mar 21, 2017 12:09 PMDerry Police say a home was shot at and struck at least 6 times early Tuesday morning, but no one was hurt. (More)
Mar 21, 2017 12:26 PMA woman has been charge with assault against three infants at a Manchester day care center. The three victims are all younger than 1-years-old....
Mar 20, 2017 4:05 PMA man who pleaded guilty to supplying a person in Rochester with a deadly dose of drugs will spend between 8- and 16-years in...
Mar 20, 2017 4:01 PMOnlyInYourState.com has provided nine places in the Granite State where you might be able to spot a ghost. (More)
Mar 20, 2017 2:31 PMPolice are searching for a man who allegedly punched and injured another man at a diner in Manchester. (More)
Mar 20, 2017 3:56 PMA 21-year-old man destroyed his family home after trying to exterminate ants with wooden matches, killing their two cats and a dog. (More)
Mar 20, 2017 4:14 PMA state representative cited house rules when she told a New Hampshire man to stop recording a committee meeting - rules that apparently do...
Mar 19, 2017 5:08 PMA new kind of roller coaster experience is set to premiere next month at Six Flags New England. (More)
Mar 20, 2017 9:40 AMAuthorities say Super Bowl LI and Super Bowl XLIX jerseys "found in the possession of a credentialed member of international media." (More)
Mar 18, 2016 10:37 AMA drug sweep on Thursday afternoon and evening netted four arrests, a pound of suspected cocaine and $7,000 in cash. (More)
Mar 19, 2017 11:56 AMDisney's live-action 'Beauty' was a beast at the box office, opening with an estimated $170 million in North American ticket sales and setting a...
Mar 19, 2017 10:06 AMToll booth workers could be a thing of the past under a bill before the New Hampshire House. (More)
Mar 19, 2017 10:48 AMA Windham man sustained life-threatening injuries when his snowmobile collided with a tree. (More)
Mar 19, 2017 11:23 AMA snowmobiler fell through thin ice, causing a difficult rescue by Wakefield Fire and EMS. (More)
Mar 18, 2017 1:33 PMA Boscawen man is accused of driving 104 mph in a 65 mph speed zone around 9:40 a.m. Saturday. (More)
Mar 17, 2017 5:07 PMAn Exeter High School guidance counselor has pleaded not guilty to aggravated sexual assault against an underage female student. (More)
Mar 17, 2017 4:26 PMA Pembroke mother held a gun to her daughter's head and shouted "You (expletive) piece of (expletive)," according to court paperwork. (More)
Mar 18, 2017 8:24 AMUtility crews are still mopping up in New Hampshire after a powerful nor'easter. (More)
Mar 17, 2017 11:30 AMA 62-year-old man passed away after his snowmobile got stuck in while attempting to get up a hill on Trail 21 in Stewartstown. (More)
Mar 17, 2017 1:13 PMThe Nashua Police Department arrested five more people for various drug-related crimes in connection with Operation Granite Hammer Thursday. (More)
Mar 17, 2017 10:37 AMCitizens Bank is experiencing transaction delays affecting customer accounts. The company acknowledged the problem on its social media accounts Friday. (More)
Mar 17, 2017 8:42 AMThe New Hampshire Attorney General identified the man who was found dead in a Farmington home Wednesday. (More)
Mar 17, 2017 7:52 AMA Pembroke mother is facing charges after allegedly pointing a gun at her daughter during an argument. (More)
Mar 17, 2017 8:22 AMPolice responded to the hotel around 11:30 p.m. to find a 43-year-old man that was "actively" bleeding due to severe injuries on his face....
Mar 16, 2017 3:35 PMAn Effingham woman pleaded guilty to selling fentanyl that caused the death of a Wolfeboro man. (More)
Mar 16, 2017 3:09 PMProsecutors recently filed a motion to revoke Earle's bail after learning she is back together with the boyfriend in question. (More)
Mar 16, 2017 9:14 AMHooksett Highway Department calls police after seeing snow was being plowed across the roadway by a private plow. (More)
Mar 16, 2017 4:16 PMThe former owner of a Manchester sports bar pleaded guilty to having and planning to distribute nearly 17 pounds of meth in largest bust...
Mar 16, 2017 7:21 AMPolice responded to a 911 call from a home at 12:06 p.m. Wednesday. Officers at the scene found one man dead, a woman injured....
Mar 15, 2017 12:05 PMA community is showing their support for a Gilford family that lost their daughter during the 2017 blizzard. (More)
Mar 15, 2017 1:23 PMThe roof of the Hampshire Dome has collapsed. Fire crews are on scene. The dome is part of the Hampshire Hills Athletic Club sports...
Mar 15, 2017 12:27 PMPolice found marijuana in a 64-year-old woman's purse after she allegedly refused a welfare check in Plaistow. (More)
Mar 15, 2017 9:43 AMHere are the latest storm reports from National Weather Service storm spotters. The snow totals have been rounded to the nearest half-inch. SOUTHERN NH Stratham – 23.5” Goffstown – 20” Nottingham – 19” Exeter – 18” East Rochester – 18” Weare – 17.5” North Brookline – 17”...
Mar 15, 2017 7:43 AMCatalano's Market and apartments burn in overnight fire. (More)
Mar 14, 2017 4:13 PMA 23-month-old child in need of a heart transplant was escorted by a convoy of plow trucks, state police and National Guardsmen from one...
Mar 14, 2017 8:30 AMThis March Nor'easter has dumped snow across New Hampshire, leaving crashes and lane closures on I-89 and I-93 as it begins to really ramp...
Mar 14, 2017 6:26 PMTens of thousands are without power in New Hampshire on Tuesday evening as the 2017 blizzard continues to hammer the state. (More)
Mar 14, 2017 11:01 AMSnow has moved into the Granite State, but the height of the storm comes Tuesday afternoon into early evening. Blizzard warnings are in effect for southeast New Hampshire, where the combination of heavy snow and strong winds will create whiteout conditions during the height of the nor'easter Tuesday afternoon....
Mar 14, 2017 4:26 PMTens of thousands are without power in New Hampshire Tuesday afternoon as the 2017 blizzard sweeps across the state. (More)
Mar 14, 2017 2:28 PMAs the winds begin to pick up across New Hampshire during the 2017 blizzard, power outages are leaving thousands in the dark. (More)