Sep 1, 2016 11:06 PM
NH1 News Political Director
CONCORD – Sen. Kelly Ayotte and her Republican primary challenger battled over illegal immigration, free trade deals, fiscal issues, special interests, and even Donald Trump, in the first debate in New Hampshire’s blockbuster U.S. Senate race.
While Ayotte’s general election match up with Gov. Maggie Hassan, her Democratic challenger, dominates the race, the incumbent still has a long shot primary challenge on her hands from former state Sen. Jim Rubens. The two candidates faced off Thursday night in an NH1 News debate.
Rubens went on the attack soon after the start of the debate, criticizing Ayotte over her 2013 vote in favor of a bipartisan immigration reform bill.
“Unfortunately Senator, you promised to vote against amnesty and to secure the border when you ran last time in 2010. And you broke that promise. You went to Washington and voted for the Gang of Eight, open borders, amnesty, drive down American wages bill,” Rubens charged.
Ayotte defended her past Senate votes on the issue, saying “I feel strongly that we need to secure our border and protect the American people. That’s why the proposal that I voted for would have doubled the amount of fencing, would have doubled the amount of border agents, would have created an entry-exit system. And in fact 40% of the people who are here illegally actually overstayed a visa so we need that system. We need a stronger E-Verify system. And I have voted to end sanctuary cities.”
A few minutes later, Rubens attacked again, this time over the Trans Pacific Partnership (TPP), a proposed free trade deal involving the U.S. and nearly a dozen Pacific nations. Last year Ayotte voted in favor of the bipartisan Trade Promotion Authority (TPA) legislation, which gave President Obama fast track authority to negotiate the TPP deal.
“We need fair trade policies that do not lead to us bleeding jobs to other countries. So I oppose TPP, I oppose TPA, because it will result in more deterioration of American wages,” he stated. “I differ with my opponent on these crony capitalist trade deals. Totally unfair for Americans.”
Ayotte disagreed, saying “I’ve visited so many great companies in New Hampshire, manufacturing companies. Companies that do great work in producing incredible goods. And they’re exporting a lot of their goods overseas and they do incredible work. And I know that our companies, they can compete in the very best, and are the very best, when there’s a fair playing field. So I did allow the President to negotiate this. But I can’t support it as it’s come forward because he did not negotiate it strongly enough.”
In a rare moment, Ayotte then mentioned the name of the GOP presidential nominee, saying “this is where I agree with Donald Trump, because I think he would be a much stronger negotiator.”
Ayotte’s kept her distance from Trump, saying she’ll vote for him but not endorse him. And in an editorial board meeting earlier this week she said that Trump has not always in the past been totally honest or trustworthy.
Asked in the NH1 News debate about that comment and whether she’d still vote for Trump, Ayotte responded “think about Sec. Hillary Clinton and the lies that she has told. I think that certainly I trust him much more than her.”
But Rubens criticized Ayotte for her stance regarding the GOP nominee, saying “I will vote for Donald Trump and I will endorse him and I have endorsed him. Anything less than this is a support for Hillary Clinton.”
A fiscal fight
Rubens also questioned Ayotte’s fiscal conservative credentials.
“You promised to be a fiscal conservative when you ran in 2010. I supported you in 2010 and worked to get you elected. You get down there. You drink the Washington cool aid and you voted for the Democrats and Obama’s cromibus and omnibus budgets. These are the last two budgets. The proof is in the vote. And you voted to add trillions of dollars to national debt,” Rubens charged.
“You voted recently, last year, to gut, to take $117 billion from the Social Security Trust Fund to fund Welfare. You voted to remove the debt ceiling. These are not the acts of a fiscal conservative. This is fundamental to what Republican stand for. We’re having a primary here so we can have people in the United States Senate who will vote for fiscal responsibility” he added.
Responding, Ayotte said “I strongly support getting our fiscal house in order.. I’ve supported a balanced budget amendment and on every committee that I serve on I’m looking for ways to cut spending and have examples of how I’ve done that. But I want people to understand the things that Mr. Rubens is criticizing me on, the bills that I did support, to make sure that the military had the funding to take on ISIS, to make sure that those resources that I talked about for the heroin epidemic were coming to New Hampshire. And also suspending the medical device tax that is so onerous under Obamacare. Those are important issues for New Hampshire that I wasn’t going to overlook.”
Late in the debate, Rubens accused Ayotte of being in the pockets of special interests.
“You’ve taken tens of millions of bucks from special interests in Washington and it’s the only way you can explain why you would vote to bankrupt the country and fill the budget with so much pork. Why you would vote to leave the borders open and why you would vote for tripling of H-1B visas that are driving down wages for technical workers right here in New Hampshire. I can’t explain it any other way,” he charged.
Ayotte shot back, saying “let me just be clear, it’s not true what Mr. Rubens just said. But let me just be clear about this. I do have special interests. People like Barbara Moussette, who was going to lose her home because she was a victim of identity theft, that I fought the IRS for. People like our veterans who need better quality care, and who I fight for every single day. Our men and women who serve at the Portsmouth Naval Shipyard, and our guard. Absolutely, every day I wake up to fight for people in New Hampshire and that’s why I do this.”
The NH1 News debate came just 12 days before the Granite State’s Sept. 13 primary.
5 hours 9 minutes agoThe New Hampshire Fish and Game Department says emergency responders have removed the body of a hiker whose body was found in the Dry...
22 hours 56 minutes agoIf you want to make a splash, you should look (at this story) before you leap. (More)
23 hours 53 minutes agoWhen the next car pulled up to the traffic detail, she frantically told police that a cat was trapped on the roof of the...
Jul 20, 2017 5:16 PMNH AG Gordon MacDonald held a press conference Thursday to report findings on the investigation into the officer-involved shooting in Hampton on June 13....
Jul 20, 2017 2:34 PMWork has begun on the property that will soon house New Hampshire's newest indoor gun range. (More)
Jul 21, 2017 8:41 AMThunderstorms hit quickly in parts of central and southern NHThursday afternoon, producing wind gusts powerful enough to knock down trees and power lines. (More)
Jul 20, 2017 9:53 AMThe Salem man's suit seeks $5.5 million for punitive damages after his car was towed and stored by a Methuen, Mass., company after an...
Jul 21, 2017 7:37 AMThe body of a New Jersey man who went missing in the White Mountains was found Thursday. (More)
Jul 20, 2017 5:11 PMNearly 4,000 customers are without power. (More)
Jul 20, 2017 4:27 PMAn investigation has determined that a gas-powered generator is to blame for the carbon monoxide poisoning death of a man in Litchfield earlier this...
Jul 20, 2017 11:16 AMThe owner of a truck may be facing charges after leaving his dog in a truck Wednesday afternoon when the temperature was in the...
Jul 19, 2017 11:15 AMChester police officer conducts adorable "traffic stop" on Edwards Mill Road Tuesday night. (More)
Jul 19, 2017 3:56 PMThe neighborhood where a 6-year-old boy apparently overdosed is familiar with the opioid crisis. (More)
Jul 19, 2017 5:38 PMThe community is mourning Ciara Brill who passed away Tuesday after battling a rare brain cancer. (More)
Jul 18, 2017 2:27 PMA Maine woman who fled to safety amid a deadly rampage says her boyfriend's father promised not to hurt her as he killed his...
Jul 20, 2017 7:11 AMArizona Sen. McCain tells Sen. Lindsey Graham, "I'll be back" following treatments after cancer discovered cancerous tumor last week. (More)
Jul 19, 2017 10:27 AMNew Hampshire is likely to get the second heat wave of the summer the next few days. Some tips on how to beat the...
Jul 19, 2017 11:22 AMAMR personnel revived a 6-year-old boy with Narcan after they found him unresponsive in Manchester. (More)
Jul 19, 2017 9:38 AMThe Manchester Veterans Administration hospital reported a "catastrophic mechanical failure" at about 4 a.m. which flooded parts of the facility. (More)
Jul 19, 2017 7:19 AMSeveral area fire departments help fight the afternoon fire. (More)
Jul 19, 2017 7:49 AMA New Hampshire lobsterman has joined an elite club after catching a rare blue lobster. (More)
Jul 18, 2017 3:22 PMA new study shows boxed macaroni and cheese has more than 4 times the amount of harmful chemical than other cheeses. (More)
Jul 18, 2017 8:13 PMNH will become the 22nd state in the nation to decriminalize simple marijuana possession thanks to a bill Governor Sununu signed into law Tuesday....
Jul 18, 2017 12:45 PMA Troy man faces 20 charges after he allegedly fled from police while drunken driving. (More)
Jul 18, 2017 12:18 PMA former dean of students at Pembroke Academy was in court Tuesday following two previous missed appearances. (More)
Jul 18, 2017 3:10 PMRochester Police had previously gotten reports that the wanted man would 'not be taken alive' and 'would shoot any officer that tried arresting him.'...
Jul 17, 2017 4:04 PMEight-month-old baby Colton recently diagnosed with a fatal genetic disease. (More)
Jul 18, 2017 12:16 PMSununu ranked towards the middle of the pack, coming in as the 19th most approved governor with a 57 percent approval rating. (More)
Jul 18, 2017 1:05 PMNew Hampshire's attorney general says a search is being conducted at a home where the bodies of two women were found in January. (More)
Jul 17, 2017 3:32 PMPolice arrest a New Hampshire man after witnesses say he dragged a woman out of his vehicle, punched her, and left her unconscious in...
Jul 17, 2017 2:06 PMA boating accident that killed a 12-year-old girl happened after her father's hat blew from his head. (More)
Jul 17, 2017 3:49 PMThose who visited Hampton Beach during the afternoon on July 9 should monitor themselves for measles symptoms. (More)
Jul 17, 2017 9:54 AMSkywatchers were buzzing over the weekend about a potential sighting of the northern lights, but most missed out on the bright lights known as...
Jul 16, 2017 4:23 PMThe Veterans Affairs Office is launching a review of the Manchester Veterans Affairs Medical Center following allegations of poor conditions and patient care. (More)
Jul 17, 2017 7:48 AMPolice say the three occupants of a 1993 Mustang were not properly restrained. Injuries came after the car hit a boulder and rolled over....
Jul 16, 2017 8:43 PMAfter a tough race, Denny Hamlin took home his first victory in nearly 28 races with the NASCAR series. (More)
Jul 15, 2017 2:49 PMThe New Hampshire State Police announced that they will be conducting a sobriety checkpoint in Bedford during the weekend of July 28, 2017. (More)
Jul 16, 2017 3:08 PMSpace weather forecasters say that a recent explosion on the sun could lead to a rare display of the bright dancing lights known as...
Jul 15, 2017 6:54 PMAn event celebrating the opening of a brand new indoor seating area at an NH Ben and Jerry's featured live music, face painting, and...
Jul 14, 2017 7:05 PMThe study shows that only 199 violent crimes were reported per 100,000 New Hampshire residents in 2015. (More)
Jul 14, 2017 11:18 AMManchester police said they participated in "Operation Poison Ivy" to improve the quality of life for residents who live in the area of Enright...
Jul 14, 2017 9:54 AMA dying veteran's wish is to hear from you. (More)
Jul 14, 2017 3:57 PMConway police officers is looking for some help from citizens after a middle-aged man reportedly went missing within the White Mountain Forest. (More)
Jul 14, 2017 8:39 AMAn NH State Representative has been charged with multiple counts of sexual assault stemming from an incident involving a 16-year-old girl in July 2016....
Jul 13, 2017 5:22 PMPolice arrested seven people on various drug charges as part of the Granite Hammer Operation. (More)
Jul 13, 2017 6:38 PMRecent sexual assault allegations at St. Paul's school in Concord sparked an investigation by the Attorney General's Office. (More)
Jul 13, 2017 7:18 PMA NH woman turned herself in at the Dover PD after a warrant was issued for charges of selling fentanyl which resulted in the...
Jul 13, 2017 4:34 PMThe Deputy Fire Marshal discussed the investigation into Wednesday's carbon monoxide incident in Litchfield which killed one man and injured a woman. (More)
Jul 13, 2017 8:36 AMA search and multiple arrest warrants lead police to arrest four people and confiscate guns, drugs and money. (More)