Sep 8, 2016 6:36 PM
NH1 News Political Director
CONCORD – The three top Democratic candidates for governor disagreed over a host of issues on Thursday, as they faced off in an NH1 News debate.
The showdown between Executive Councilor Colin Van Ostern, Mark Connolly, who served nearly a decade as New Hampshire’s top financial watchdog, and former Portsmouth Mayor Steve Marchand, was the last TV debate in the race for the Corner Office before Tuesday’s primary.
The three candidates didn’t see eye to eye over the business profits tax, the gas tax, the tobacco tax, the Northern Pass transmission lines, and legalizing marijuana. And Connolly criticized Van Ostern for touting he "cast the deciding vote" to implement Medicaid expansion.
That moment occurred at the start of the debate, during a discussion of the state's heroin and opioid epidemic.
"When we extended Medicaid health care coverage to 50,000 people. It was an extraordinary effort. It took a lot of work from a lot of people. I was proud to cast the deciding vote to implement that. That also brought $608 million into our state and thousands of those people are getting treatment, specifically for substance misuse disorder, Van Ostern said.
Speaking moments later, Connolly took aim at his rival.
"I will say Colin with all due respect, you said you were the deciding vote on Medicaid Expansion. Medicaid expansion is important here. It address almost 40% of the problem in terms of people who were addicted but this is the legislature who did this. You voted on the contract. So to say that you were the deciding vote was a little bit of an exaggeration," Connolly said.
Van Ostern pushed back, saying "I’m proud to be the one person, Democrat or Republican, who was part of that process. And part of that progress. It took a determined governor, even after it failed twice. One of those times I worked with her to ask the legislature to come back to a special session to deal with it. It took bipartisan compromise. And then it came down to a three-to-two vote to get it done. And if that had been a two-to-three vote, 49,660 people wouldn’t have the health care coverage they have right now."
Connolly and Marchand clashed a few minutes later, over legalizing recreational marijuana.
After Connolly and Van Ostern urged caution in the push for legalization, Marchand criticized both of them.
"You heard in different ways from both of my opponents just now a seemingly inability to walk and chew gum at the same time. Mark mentioned that we have to work with the opioid crisis and then we could deal with marijuana and they’re not concurrent. I would argue one of the tactics towards dealing with the heroin and opioid crisis is the legalization of marijuana for the reason I said earlier, because 80% of people who use heroin started on prescription opioids," he said.
In one of the more heated moments in the debate, Connolly returned fire.
"I was in state government for 15 years Steve. And I will tell you with all due respect, you haven’t been in state service and it takes a lot of input from the departments, the towns, the cities, the people who actually implement these things. And to say we’re going to legalize a framework, I think is short sighted quite frankly. And I will tell you in my 15 years in state government, I’ve realized that there are priorities that you have to take on as governor and I think we can do this but when we hear people like (Colorado) Gov. Hickenlooper say that he recommends that states that are thinking about doing it, take some time and learn from the experience, I think that’s something we should heed and take," Connolly said.
Disagreements over tobacco, gas, and business taxes
Marchand, who's campaign organization pales to that of Van Ostern or Connolly, has been the most vocal candidate in the Democratic gubernatorial primary race. And he fired away at his two rival again, this time over raising the cigarette tax.
Discussing how to pay for full-day kindergarten, Van Ostern said "we are funding half the cost of kindergarteners. That’s why many communities only have half day kindergarten. But they don’t cost any less. And arguably they are the most important of our kids, so that they can start on an even playing field with every other child, we need to fund the full cost that we do for every other student and it will cost around $13 million a year. That is roughly the amount of money that we could raise if our cigarette taxes, which would still be lower than every other state in New England, we’re a dime a pack more."
A moment later Marchand weighed in, saying of his rivals that "both favor raising the tobacco tax by ten cents a pack. I have said repeatedly that I think that is a very back idea for public policy. The only way you raise the revenue that they hope to raise is if people continue to smoke. I think it’s a regressive tax."
Responding, Connolly said "in the economic classes that I took if you increase a tax on something, demand usually goes down. But let me say this, certainly if we have the lowest tobacco tax in New England, which we do, and we have an opioid crisis, which we’ve talked about, increasing the cigarette tax by a dime and putting that into the opioid crisis just makes good public policy sense."
The candidates were also asked whether sex education should be mandated in public schools, and if so, at what age.
"I believe that it should and at what age should be decided not by politicians but by educators," Van Ostern answered.
Marchand said that "sex education is appropriate. It should be mandated. The exact age should be taken care of at the local school district level."
There was a similar answer from Connolly, who said "certainly education about sex is important. Mandated, yes. But also has to have input from the communities and the parents."
There was disagreement when it came to taxes.
Asked whether the business profits tax, which was raised this year, should be left alone, raised, or lowered, Connolly said "I think we should let it go for a while and see what happens."
He also favored raising the state's gas tax.
Marchand said "I would increase the gas tax."
But he urged a lowering of the business profits tax, saying "I think it would be shameful if the Democratic nominee for governor in affect embraced the same position that Chris Sununu or Ted Gatsas has on reducing the business profits tax."
Van Ostern argued for keeping both taxes steady.
"One of the lessons I learned I the private sector is predictability is one of the things that businesses depend on most in their government. We’ve made significant recent changes to both just in the past recent years. I don’t think we should be making more changes and cause more unpredictability for our business or our drivers or our citizens."
On the proposed Northern Pass hydroelectric project, which would bring power from Canada, Van Ostern said "I’m not going to be closed minded about this. If they’re willing to bury the thing then I think we should look" at the project.
Marchand touted that "I’m the only candidate 100% opposed to Northern Pass. Even if you bury it, it doesn’t help rate payers in New Hampshire."
And he described lines as "a super highway with no exit ramps and it just happens to go right through New Hampshire."
Connolly shot back, saying "I don’t’ agree with that characterization."
"I think we bury these lines as much as possible. I’m not sure they can bury all of them," he added.
And he said "just to dismiss this" is wrong.
The candidates disagreed late in the debate when asked whether they would, as governor, advocate for a state ban on high power, high capacity weapons, if no federal ban were imposed.
Connolly touted that "I was the first candidate on either side to come out and say we need to do this."
Marchand said "certainly I’m open to it. We need to try to do this in cooperation with our neighbors as much as possible. I live in Portsmouth. If we put a ban in in New Hampshire, if somebody wants to go across the bridge to Kittery and they have a separate law that is significantly different it would obviously not have the intended effect."
Regarding a ban, Van Ostern said "I think that should be a last resort."
12 minutes 42 seconds agoSnow fell faster than expected today, accumulating a few inches in parts of central and northern New Hampshire through late-afternoon. (More)
6 hours 30 minutes agoNew Hampshire State Police arrested to wanted fugitives after stopping a van full of people who entered the United States illegally. (More)
2 hours 6 minutes agoA Massachusetts man has been charged with sexually assaulting a juvenile male who lives in Londonderry NH. The man met the victim in an...
23 hours 47 minutes agoState Police rearrested a Wales man for stealing electricity from a Central Maine Power pole and transformer. (More)
23 hours 4 minutes agoA Stafford County corrections officer allegedly tried bringing thousands of dollars of drugs into the jail was supposed to get deployed. (More)
4 hours 54 minutes agoIt's the first Friday of spring, but Granite Staters will have some snow to deal with. (More)
7 hours 1 minute agoThe effort to crack down on drug-related crimes - known NH-wide as Operation Granite Hammer - led to the arrests of 2 suspected heroin...
Mar 23, 2017 3:02 PMA Keene man was indicted for allegedly strangling two of his then-girlfriend's cats. (More)
Mar 23, 2017 1:28 PMDemocrats filed a complaint with the ethics committee arguing Sununu violated rules against using his position to secure advantages for himself or others. (More)
Mar 22, 2017 5:27 PMNicole Guida, owner of Chic & Unique, a boutique shop located in Littleton, is requesting a jury trial against a former customer who caused...
Mar 22, 2017 6:02 PMA Strafford County corrections officer allegedly attempted to bring heroin into the jail before being detained by police. (More)
Mar 22, 2017 11:01 AMChelsea Blais plead not guilty to abusing children in her care at the Alpha Bits Learning Center, where police say she force fed and...
Mar 22, 2017 10:15 AMNYPD seized over $4.1 million and over three kilograms (6 pounds) of heroin, unraveling a multi-state drug ring — involving New England. (More)
Mar 22, 2017 4:06 PMNew Hampshire is often in the 'weather battle zone' this time of year, which isn't a good thing if you are looking for spring...
Mar 22, 2017 10:45 AMNew Hampshire’s top public officials Wednesday marked the death of state Sen. Scott McGilvray. The first term Democratic state senator from Hooksett and president...
Mar 22, 2017 7:33 AMThe National Weather Service has issued a wind advisory from 10 a.m. Wednesday to midnight. (More)
Mar 21, 2017 10:29 PMA report released on Tuesday by the state agency that licenses childcare centers revealed multiple incidents of verbal and physical abuse committed by a...
Mar 21, 2017 6:40 PMA mother and her friend who injected her with heroin while she was in labor in September 2016 will not be facing felony charges...
Mar 21, 2017 4:09 PMA 74-year-old Mass. man living in public housing for the elderly faces drug trafficking charges after police say they found cocaine valued at about...
Mar 21, 2017 12:09 PMDerry Police say a home was shot at and struck at least 6 times early Tuesday morning, but no one was hurt. (More)
Mar 21, 2017 12:26 PMA woman has been charge with assault against three infants at a Manchester day care center. The three victims are all younger than 1-years-old....
Mar 20, 2017 4:05 PMA man who pleaded guilty to supplying a person in Rochester with a deadly dose of drugs will spend between 8- and 16-years in...
Mar 20, 2017 4:01 PMOnlyInYourState.com has provided nine places in the Granite State where you might be able to spot a ghost. (More)
Mar 20, 2017 2:31 PMPolice are searching for a man who allegedly punched and injured another man at a diner in Manchester. (More)
Mar 20, 2017 3:56 PMA 21-year-old man destroyed his family home after trying to exterminate ants with wooden matches, killing their two cats and a dog. (More)
Mar 20, 2017 4:14 PMA state representative cited house rules when she told a New Hampshire man to stop recording a committee meeting - rules that apparently do...
Mar 19, 2017 5:08 PMA new kind of roller coaster experience is set to premiere next month at Six Flags New England. (More)
Mar 20, 2017 9:40 AMAuthorities say Super Bowl LI and Super Bowl XLIX jerseys "found in the possession of a credentialed member of international media." (More)
Mar 18, 2016 10:37 AMA drug sweep on Thursday afternoon and evening netted four arrests, a pound of suspected cocaine and $7,000 in cash. (More)
Mar 19, 2017 11:56 AMDisney's live-action 'Beauty' was a beast at the box office, opening with an estimated $170 million in North American ticket sales and setting a...
Mar 19, 2017 10:06 AMToll booth workers could be a thing of the past under a bill before the New Hampshire House. (More)
Mar 19, 2017 10:48 AMA Windham man sustained life-threatening injuries when his snowmobile collided with a tree. (More)
Mar 19, 2017 11:23 AMA snowmobiler fell through thin ice, causing a difficult rescue by Wakefield Fire and EMS. (More)
Mar 18, 2017 1:33 PMA Boscawen man is accused of driving 104 mph in a 65 mph speed zone around 9:40 a.m. Saturday. (More)
Mar 17, 2017 5:07 PMAn Exeter High School guidance counselor has pleaded not guilty to aggravated sexual assault against an underage female student. (More)
Mar 17, 2017 4:26 PMA Pembroke mother held a gun to her daughter's head and shouted "You (expletive) piece of (expletive)," according to court paperwork. (More)
Mar 18, 2017 8:24 AMUtility crews are still mopping up in New Hampshire after a powerful nor'easter. (More)
Mar 17, 2017 11:30 AMA 62-year-old man passed away after his snowmobile got stuck in while attempting to get up a hill on Trail 21 in Stewartstown. (More)
Mar 17, 2017 1:13 PMThe Nashua Police Department arrested five more people for various drug-related crimes in connection with Operation Granite Hammer Thursday. (More)
Mar 17, 2017 10:37 AMCitizens Bank is experiencing transaction delays affecting customer accounts. The company acknowledged the problem on its social media accounts Friday. (More)
Mar 17, 2017 8:42 AMThe New Hampshire Attorney General identified the man who was found dead in a Farmington home Wednesday. (More)
Mar 17, 2017 7:52 AMA Pembroke mother is facing charges after allegedly pointing a gun at her daughter during an argument. (More)
Mar 17, 2017 8:22 AMPolice responded to the hotel around 11:30 p.m. to find a 43-year-old man that was "actively" bleeding due to severe injuries on his face....
Mar 16, 2017 3:35 PMAn Effingham woman pleaded guilty to selling fentanyl that caused the death of a Wolfeboro man. (More)
Mar 16, 2017 3:09 PMProsecutors recently filed a motion to revoke Earle's bail after learning she is back together with the boyfriend in question. (More)
Mar 16, 2017 9:14 AMHooksett Highway Department calls police after seeing snow was being plowed across the roadway by a private plow. (More)
Mar 16, 2017 4:16 PMThe former owner of a Manchester sports bar pleaded guilty to having and planning to distribute nearly 17 pounds of meth in largest bust...
Mar 16, 2017 7:21 AMPolice responded to a 911 call from a home at 12:06 p.m. Wednesday. Officers at the scene found one man dead, a woman injured....
Mar 15, 2017 12:05 PMA community is showing their support for a Gilford family that lost their daughter during the 2017 blizzard. (More)